TL;DR
Get workout gear delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
A large South Korean observational study linked higher BMI in adults ages 20 to 39 with higher cancer incidence over follow-up, with the association remaining into middle age. Absolute 10-year rates were low, and the findings do not establish that obesity caused cancer or that weight loss lowers risk.
A study of 6.3 million South Korean adults ages 20 to 39 found that higher body mass index (BMI) in young adulthood was associated with a greater likelihood of cancer over the following years, with the association persisting into middle age. The findings, reported in Annals of Internal Medicine, are observational and do not show that obesity caused the cancers.
Researchers used South Korea’s national health insurance database to identify adults who had at least one national health examination between 2009 and 2012. Participants were followed for an average of 11.2 years, during which 151,893 cancers were recorded. The analysis adjusted for factors including smoking status, alcohol intake, physical activity, income, residential area and existing health conditions.
The 10-year cumulative incidence of any cancer was 1.84% among people of normal weight, compared with 2.24% for class I obesity and 2.62% for class II obesity, using BMI categories for Asian populations. Compared with normal-weight participants, the estimated cancer hazard rose with BMI: 1.10 for overweight, 1.22 for class I obesity and 1.43 for class II obesity. These are relative hazard estimates, not the percentage of participants who developed cancer.
The association was stronger among men than women across the reported BMI categories. Waist circumference and abdominal obesity also provided information beyond BMI alone: for example, people with class I obesity and abdominal obesity had a 10-year cumulative incidence of 2.45%, versus 2.13% for those with class I obesity without abdominal obesity. Cancer rates were highest for thyroid, endometrial and ovarian cancers in the study’s cancer-type analysis, followed by colorectal, kidney, liver and pancreatic cancers. The report said breast cancer rates were lower among participants with obesity than among those of normal weight.
Why Early-Adult Weight Patterns Matter
The results add evidence about cancer risk in an age group that has been less represented in earlier research. The study authors said cancer prevention efforts have often focused on middle-aged and older adults, while early-onset cancers have increased in recent years. The findings may inform future research into how risk develops across adulthood, but they do not establish a basis for changing screening recommendations for young adults.
The absolute rates offer important perspective: even in the class II obesity group, the reported 10-year incidence of any cancer was 2.62%. The differences between groups were modest in absolute terms, despite rising relative hazards. The researchers and an outside expert also identified possible contributions from other factors, so the association should not be interpreted as an individual prediction or proof that changing weight will prevent cancer.
Products Worth Considering
Withings Body Smart Wi-Fi and Bluetooth Smart Scale
OMRON VIVA 360+ Body Composition Monitor and Smart Scale
Withings Body Scan Smart Scale with Segmental Body Composition and ECG, Black
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
How the South Korean Study Was Built
The research team, led by Kyungdo Han, PhD, of Soongsil University in Seoul, defined young adults as people ages 20 to 39. The cohort’s mean age was 30.9, and 59.3% of participants were men. BMI was grouped using World Health Organization criteria adapted for Asian populations; participants were also categorized by waist circumference and abdominal obesity.
Alpa Patel, PhD, of the American Cancer Society, who was not involved in the study, told MedPage Today that the work provides added information on early-onset cancers and uses a contemporary population, with follow-up beginning in 2009–2012. Patel cautioned that the analysis recorded smoking status but not smoking intensity or duration, both of which can affect cancer risk. The source report also noted that people in higher BMI categories were more likely to smoke at the time of the health examination.
“Although the absolute risk differences were modest, the consistency of associations across multiple cancer types and the young age of the population underscore the potential importance of early-life weight management.”
— Kyungdo Han, PhD, and colleagues, as quoted in the study report
Limits on Cause and Individual Risk
The study shows an association, not proof of cause. Although researchers adjusted for several measured factors, unmeasured or incompletely measured influences may remain. Patel specifically noted that smoking intensity and duration were not reported, limiting how fully smoking-related risk could be accounted for.
The results also do not show whether intentional weight loss in early adulthood reduces later cancer risk. Nor do they establish which young adults, if any, would benefit from earlier screening. The reported rates apply to this South Korean cohort and its definitions and follow-up period; they should not be treated as direct estimates for every country or individual. The lower breast cancer rate reported among participants with obesity is an observation in this analysis, not evidence that obesity protects against breast cancer.
Prospective Research and Screening
The authors called for prospective studies to test whether intentional weight loss in early adulthood is associated with lower subsequent cancer risk. Further research could also clarify how abdominal fat, BMI, cancer type and other risk factors relate to outcomes in younger adults.
For now, the study does not announce a screening change or establish a new clinical recommendation. Whether early cancer screening should be considered for some young adults with obesity remains an open question identified by the researchers. No specific follow-up study, policy decision or timeline was provided in the report.
Key Questions
Does the study prove obesity causes cancer in young adults?
No. It was an observational study that found an association between higher BMI and cancer incidence. It cannot establish that obesity caused the cancers.
How many people took part, and how long were they followed?
The analysis included 6.3 million adults ages 20 to 39 who had a national health examination between 2009 and 2012. Average follow-up was 11.2 years.
What were the 10-year cancer rates by weight category?
The reported cumulative incidence of any cancer was 1.84% for normal-weight participants, 2.24% for those with class I obesity and 2.62% for those with class II obesity, using Asian-specific BMI categories.
Does this mean young adults with obesity should start cancer screening earlier?
The study does not establish a screening recommendation. The authors said more research is needed to identify whether early screening might be warranted for any young adults with obesity.
Did the study show that losing weight lowers cancer risk?
No. The researchers called for prospective studies to determine whether intentional weight loss in early adulthood reduces later cancer risk; this analysis did not test that question.
Source: medpagetoday.com
